← Back

The Tragedy of Ecological Rights of Mangroves and Marine Ecosystems Trapped Behind Fences!

Sea Fences; Built long ago, their presence only recently realized

• The construction of sea fences in Bekasi has been ongoing since June 2023, yet went viral in early January 2025.

• The construction of sea fences in Tangerang Regency, Banten began in July 2024, yet went viral in early January 2025.

• Sea fences across Island C in North Jakarta have existed since October 2024 before being reported in January 2025.

While the installation of sea fences provides the positive value of reducing abrasion from ocean waves and accelerating accretion, why has it become a problem? Are there consequences we might not be aware of? Let's take a closer look at how sea fences affect the environment!

What Are Ecological Rights?

Definition: Ecological rights are the rights of the environment and ecosystems to remain sustainable.

Aspects/Components:

o The right of ecosystems not to suffer degradation due to human activities.

o The right of the community to enjoy a healthy and sustainable environment.

o The right of future generations to continue accessing existing natural resources.

In the context of sea fences, the ignored ecological rights are the destruction of mangrove habitats and the disruption of marine ecosystems.

Impact of Sea Fences on Mangroves

1. Stunted Mangrove Growth: Sea fences block water flow and the distribution of mangrove seeds, disrupting natural mangrove regeneration that depends on ocean tides.

2. Increased Coastal Abrasion and Erosion: Without mangroves, coasts are more vulnerable to waves and abrasion. Studies on the coast of Java show that the loss of 1 hectare of mangroves can increase abrasion by up to 2 meters per year.

3. Disruption of Spawning Processes: Mangroves are spawning grounds for fish, crabs, and shrimp. Without mangroves, these habitats are disrupted.

Impact of Sea Fences on Marine Ecosystems

1. Disruption of Nutrient Flow and Marine Biota Movement

o Sea fences block the movement of fish and plankton, reducing species diversity.

o Sea fences can alter ocean current dynamics, which may degrade water quality and marine habitats.

o WWF data (2022) shows that artificial barriers in the ocean can decrease fish populations by up to 35% within 5 years.

2. Increased Water Turbidity

o Sea fences can obstruct ocean currents, causing sediments carried by the currents to become trapped around the fences. This can disrupt the photosynthesis process of marine plants.

3. Loss of Habitats for Fish and Marine Biota

o With sea fences, many species lose their breeding grounds.

o Sea fences can damage coral reefs, which are sensitive marine ecosystems.

Instead of solely relying on sea fences, a more visionary and sustainable approach is needed—encompassing mangrove ecosystem restoration, artificial coral reef engineering, and ecosystem-based coastal management, offering more holistic and long-lasting solutions for the future!!

It is time to open our eyes and take action—not by restricting the sea with fences, but by caring for its ecosystem. Protect mangroves, maintain marine balance, and stop practices that strip away ecological rights!

SMART ACTIONS FOR SMART ISLAND!

_References_

• https://www.tempo.co/politik/ombudsman-nilai-alasan-jrp-soal-pembangunan-pagar-laut-di-tangerang-tidak-logis-1194598

• https://www.kompas.com/tren/read/2025/01/15/050000165/teka-teki-pemilik-pagar-laut-bekasi-terungkap-siapa-dalang-di-baliknya-?page=all

• https://www.kompasiana.com/arrayan17571/67a31171ed64153e213a6f64/dampak-pagar-laut-bagi-ekosistem-laut

• https://www.rri.co.id/sulawesi-selatan/editorial/2533/dampak-fenomena-pagar-laut-di-perairan-indonesia#:~:text=Kemunculan%20pagar%20laut%20ini%20menimbulkan,masyarakat%20pesisir%2C%20dan%20generasi%20penerus.

• https://binus.ac.id/character-building/2024/09/hak-warga-negara-ekologis/

• https://www.jituproperty.com/articles/dampak-negatif-pagar-laut-apa-yang-harus-kita-tahu-561?page=all#:~:text=Dampak%20Negatif%20Pagar%20Laut%20Terhadap%20Kualitas%20Air,hasil%20laut%20sebagai%20sumber%20penghidupan

• Andi Gustiani Salim, Harris Herman Siringoringo, and Budi Hadi Narendra, THE INFLUENCE OF MANGROVE COVER ON SHORELINE CHANGES AND SEAWATER INTRUSION IN THE DOWNSTREAM OF CIASEM AND CIPUNEGARA WATERSHEDS, SUBANG REGENCY, J. MANUSIA DAN LINGKUNGAN, Vol. 23, No.3, September 2016: 319-326,